1. Silahkan Login atau Register, untuk melihat konten-konten menarik lainnya.
  2. Pengen ganti nama ID? Plat tambahan? Promo GK? Cek Promo Spesial Hari Kemerdekaan, Kuy~ Cek infonya di sini yaa!
  3. Tim staff IDWS mengajak dan memberikan kesempatan IDWS Mania bergabung dalam tim staff komunitas forum IDWS nih. Klik untuk info lengkapnya yuk~
  4. Hai IDWS Mania, membership gatotkaca telah hadir kembali lho, kalau mau info lebih lanjut klik di sini
  5. Eh, eh.. IDWS punya kebijakan baru dan Moderator in Trainee baru loh!. Intip di sini kuy!

Discussion Talk about novels adapted into films or movies

Discussion in 'Books' started by imouto_chan, Jan 4, 2015.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. imouto_chan M V U

    Offline

    Lurking Around

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2014
    Messages:
    839
    Trophy Points:
    32
    Ratings:
    +153 / -17
    [SIZE=+3]Talk about novels adapted into films or movies[/SIZE]



    Menyesuaikan dengan tema lounge SF Books ke 7
    Yuk kita ngomongin semuanya tentang novel yg diadaptasikan/dibuatkan versi film dan movienya :siul:


    Apa aj sih novel2 yg adaptasinya dbuat dengan begitu baik :terharu:
    Perbedaan apa aj yg ada diantara ke2 versi tsb
    Trus impresi apa yg kalian dapatkan begitu tahu dan nonton versi film/movie dari novel yg kalian suka

    Atau sebaliknya adaptasi novel mana yg bikin kalian sakit hati karena sudah merusak image yg kalian bayangin dari storynya :kecewa:


    Mau ngeshare list novel yg kira2 menarik menurut kalian bt direalisasikan movienya jg boleh ko


    Intinya lets talk about novels adapted into films or movies :hmm:
     
    Last edited: Jan 4, 2015
  2. Ramasinta Tukang Iklan





  3. fuikisama MODERATOR

    Offline

    Superstar

    Joined:
    Mar 24, 2012
    Messages:
    18,015
    Trophy Points:
    258
    Ratings:
    +23,392 / -180
    Reserved dulu kl gtu mah





    Sawachika [​IMG]
     
  4. Ramasinta Tukang Iklan





  5. fuikisama MODERATOR

    Offline

    Superstar

    Joined:
    Mar 24, 2012
    Messages:
    18,015
    Trophy Points:
    258
    Ratings:
    +23,392 / -180
    Reserved dulu kl gtu mah +2





    Sawachika [​IMG]
     
  6. Ramasinta Tukang Iklan





  7. imouto_chan M V U

    Offline

    Lurking Around

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2014
    Messages:
    839
    Trophy Points:
    32
    Ratings:
    +153 / -17
    Reserveb bt index 1


























































































































































































































































































    [​IMG]
    The Devil Wears Prada
    Author: Lauren Weisberger

    • Currently 3.7/5 Stars.
    277
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2006







    TagsChick lit, Fashion Industry, fashion, New York City, books made into movies, Lauren Weisberger



    [​IMG]
    Seabiscuit
    Author: Laura Hillenbrand

    • Currently 4/5 Stars.
    511
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2003







    Tagshorse racing, horses, Seabiscuit, horse story, made into a movie, movie, Non-Fiction, books made into movies, horse, true story



    [​IMG]
    The Secret Life of Bees
    Author: Sue Monk Kidd

    • Currently 4/5 Stars.
    5441
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2003








    TagsNew York Times Bestseller, Civil rights, bees, coming of age, South Carolina, Southern fiction, sue monk kidd, Fiction, family, movie



    [​IMG]
    The Da Vinci Code (Robert Langdon, Bk 2)
    Author: Dan Brown

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    2057
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2006







    Tagsdan brown, Mystery, Thriller, movie, robert langdon, Fiction, da vinci, da vinci code, mystery & thriller, religion



    [​IMG]
    The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants
    Author: Ann Brashares

    • Currently 4/5 Stars.
    821
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2003








    TagsSisterhood, Teen Fiction, Chick lit, New York Times Bestseller, Young Adult Fiction, made into a movie, traveling pants series, ann brashares, friendship,sisterhood series



    [​IMG]
    The Horse Whisperer
    Author: Nicholas Evans

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    771
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 1996







    Tagshorses, New York Times Bestseller, Romance, Fiction, Nicholas Evans, books made into movies, contemporary fiction, horse, horse fiction, made into movie



    [​IMG]
    Friday Night Lights: A Town, a Team, and a Dream
    Author: H. G. Bissinger

    • Currently 3.7/5 Stars.
    42
    Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
    Publication Date: 2004







    TagsFootball, books made into movies, TV series, movie



    [​IMG]
    Ella Enchanted
    Author: Gail Carson Levine

    • Currently 4.3/5 Stars.
    201
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 1998







    TagsFantasy, Newbery Honor Book, books made into movies, Gail Carson Levine, ella enchanted



    [​IMG]
    The Perfect Storm: A True Story of Men Against the Sea
    Author: Sebastian Junger

    • Currently 3.7/5 Stars.
    378
    Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
    Publication Date: 1998







    TagsNon-Fiction, true story, Suspense, made into a movie, books made into movies, sea, Movie Tie-in, adventure, maritime, movie



    [​IMG]
    Hannibal (Hannibal Lechter, Bk 3)
    Author: Thomas Harris

    • Currently 3.7/5 Stars.
    235
    Book Type: Hardcover
    Publication Date: 1999







    Tagsbooks made into movies, movie



    [​IMG]
    Nights in Rodanthe
    Author: Nicholas Sparks

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    752
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2004







    TagsRomance, nicholas sparks, Fiction, Nights in Rodanthe, romance > contemporary, books made into movies, Bestselling Author, Movie Tie-In Version with Richard Gere and Diane Lane, drama, made into a movie



    [​IMG]
    The Notebook
    Author: Nicholas Sparks

    • Currently 4/5 Stars.
    1691
    Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
    Publication Date: 2004







    TagsRomance, nicholas sparks, movie, The Notebook, Fiction, Love story, books made into movies, love, romance > contemporary, tearjerker



    [​IMG]
    A Walk to Remember
    Author: Nicholas Sparks

    • Currently 4/5 Stars.
    1020
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2000







    Tagsnicholas sparks, Fiction, Romance, Movie Tie-in, Love story, books made into movies, love



    [​IMG]
    The Hours
    Author: Michael Cunningham

    • Currently 3.4/5 Stars.
    424
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2002







    TagsPulitzer Prize Fiction, movie, 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die, Movie Tie-in, Novel, Pulitzer Prize, books made into movies, made into a movie, made into movie, Meryl Streep



    [​IMG]
    The Runaway Jury
    Author: John Grisham

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    996
    Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
    Publication Date: 1997







    TagsJohn Grisham, Legal Thriller, Thriller, Fiction, Mystery, legal fiction, Judicial System, Suspense, books made into movies, courtroom drama



    [​IMG]
    The Bourne Ultimatum (Bourne, Bk 3)
    Author: Robert Ludlum

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    319
    Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
    Publication Date: 1991







    TagsBourne Series, Jason Bourne, Action, Thriller, Robert Ludlum, movie, CIA, Espionage, Movie Tie-in, books made into movies



    [​IMG]
    The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants
    Author: Ann Brashares

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    260
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2005







    TagsSisterhood, friendship, movie, traveling pants series, young adult, 1st in Series, Teen, books made into movies, pants, traveling



    [​IMG]
    Cold Mountain
    Author: Charles Frazier

    • Currently 3.7/5 Stars.
    691
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 1998







    TagsCivil War Fiction, Historical Fiction, National Book Award winner, Civil War, Fiction, charles frazier, movie, Nicole Kidman, cold mountain, made into a movie



    [​IMG]
    The Hours
    Author: Michael Cunningham

    • Currently 3.6/5 Stars.
    386
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2000








    TagsPulitzer Prize Fiction, 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die, Fiction, Pen/Faulkner Award, books made into movies, made into a movie



    [​IMG]
    The Bridges of Madison County (Audio Cassettes) (Unabridged)
    Author: Robert James Waller

    • Currently 3.6/5 Stars.
    10
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 1992







    Tagsbooks made into movies



    [​IMG]
    Seabiscuit: An American Legend
    Author: Laura Hillenbrand

    • Currently 4/5 Stars.
    368
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2002








    Tagshorse racing, horses, biography, Non-Fiction, Historical, New York Times notable book, Seabiscuit, movie, History, books made into movies



    [​IMG]
    The Devil Wears Prada
    Author: Lauren Weisberger

    • Currently 3.6/5 Stars.
    850
    Book Type: Mass Market Paperback
    Publication Date: 2006







    TagsChick lit, movie, fashion, Movie Tie-in, New York City, made into a movie, Fiction, books made into movies, prada, women's fiction



    [​IMG]
    Snow Falling on Cedars
    Author: David Guterson

    • Currently 3.7/5 Stars.
    1018
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 1995








    TagsJapanese Americans, Pen/Faulkner Award, Fiction, Historical Fiction, bestseller, American Literature, Movie Tie-in, Murder, Pacific northwest, award winner



    [​IMG]
    Chocolat
    Author: Joanne Harris

    • Currently 3.9/5 Stars.
    231
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2000







    TagsMovie Tie-in, Romance, chocolate, johnny depp, made into a movie, Literature and Fiction, Love story, books made into movies, family secrets, joanne harris



    [​IMG]
    Prince Caspian (Chronicles of Narnia, Bk 2)
    Author: C. S. Lewis

    • Currently 4.4/5 Stars.
    153
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 1970







    TagsChristian Fiction, Narnia, books made into movies



    [​IMG]
    Cold Mountain
    Author: Charles Frazier

    • Currently 3.7/5 Stars.
    253
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2003







    TagsHistorical Fiction, Civil War, Fiction, movie, Love story, National Book Award winner, Romance, books made into movies



    [​IMG]
    Schindler's List
    Author: Thomas Keneally

    • Currently 4.1/5 Stars.
    225
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 1993








    TagsHolocaust, World War II, Booker Prize Winner, Historical Fiction, History, Jewish, bestseller, books made into movies



    [​IMG]
    The Devil Wears Prada
    Author: Lauren Weisberger

    • Currently 3.6/5 Stars.
    1720
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2004








    TagsChick lit, fashion, made into a movie, Fashion Industry, movie, New York City, Lauren Weisberger, women's fiction, New York Times Bestseller, first job



    [​IMG]
    Into the Wild
    Author: Jon Krakauer

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    455
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2007








    TagsAlaska, Into the Wild, National Bestseller, Non-Fiction, biography, books made into movies, made into a movie, movie



    [​IMG]
    Le Divorce (William Abrahams Book)
    Author: Diane Johnson

    • Currently 3.1/5 Stars.
    63
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2003








    TagsFrance, books made into movies



    [​IMG]
    Bridge to Terabithia
    Author: Katherine Paterson

    • Currently 4.2/5 Stars.
    58
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2007







    TagsNewbery Medal Winner, Children's book, books made into movies



    [​IMG]
    House of Sand and Fog
    Author: Andre Dubus III

    • Currently 3.7/5 Stars.
    796
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2000







    TagsOprah Book Club, Fiction, Oprah's Book Club, National Book Award finalist, Fiction Novel, Movie Tie-in, Trade Size, movie, Thriller, made into movie



    [​IMG]
    Aquamarine
    Author: Alice Hoffman

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    70
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2002







    TagsMermaids, Children's book, Ages 9-12, Children 9-12, Fantasy, Movie Tie-in, books made into movies, friendship



    [​IMG]
    Riding in Cars With Boys: Confessions of a Bad Girl Who Makes Good
    Author: Beverley Donofrio

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    86
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2001







    Tagsbooks made into movies, memoir



    [​IMG]
    The Pursuit of Happyness
    Author: Chris Gardner

    • Currently 3.6/5 Stars.
    176
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2006







    Tagsbiography, books made into movies, made into a movie, memoir



    [​IMG]
    Atonement
    Author: Ian McEwan

    • Currently 3.3/5 Stars.
    366
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2007







    Tagsmovie, Love story, National Bestseller, 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die, romance > historical, Historical Fiction, Romance, books made into movies,made into movie, tragedy



    [​IMG]
    The Lovely Bones
    Author: Alice Sebold

    • Currently 3.9/5 Stars.
    2218
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2004







    TagsMurder, Alice Sebold, Fiction, movie, afterlife, heaven, the lovely bones, Mystery, bestseller, death



    [​IMG]
    White Oleander
    Author: Janet Fitch

    • Currently 3.8/5 Stars.
    823
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 1999







    TagsOprah Book Club, Oprah's Book Club, made into a movie, Fiction, Movie Tie-in, coming of age, foster care, mother daughter relationships, mothers and daughters, books made into movies



    [​IMG]
    The Stepford Wives
    Author: Ira Levin

    • Currently 3.2/5 Stars.
    76
    Book Type: Paperback
    Publication Date: 2004







    Tagsmovie, books made into movies, made into a movie



    [​IMG]
    Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood (Ya Yas, Bk 2)
    Author: Rebecca Wells

    • Currently 3.6/5 Stars.
    461
    Book Type: Mass Market Paperback







    TagsFiction, Ya Yas, made into a movie, Chick lit, books made into movies, women

     
    • Like Like x 1
    Last edited: Jan 4, 2015
  8. Ramasinta Tukang Iklan





  9. imouto_chan M V U

    Offline

    Lurking Around

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2014
    Messages:
    839
    Trophy Points:
    32
    Ratings:
    +153 / -17
    Reserved bt index 2
     
  10. Ramasinta Tukang Iklan





  11. imouto_chan M V U

    Offline

    Lurking Around

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2014
    Messages:
    839
    Trophy Points:
    32
    Ratings:
    +153 / -17
    Reserved bt index 3
     
  12. Ramasinta Tukang Iklan





  13. imouto_chan M V U

    Offline

    Lurking Around

    Joined:
    Oct 11, 2014
    Messages:
    839
    Trophy Points:
    32
    Ratings:
    +153 / -17
    Reserved bt index 4
     
  14. Ramasinta Tukang Iklan





  15. fuikisama MODERATOR

    Offline

    Superstar

    Joined:
    Mar 24, 2012
    Messages:
    18,015
    Trophy Points:
    258
    Ratings:
    +23,392 / -180
    Hmm...
    Mulai dri yg ptama kali dulu mungkin ya :obiii:

    Klo novel lokal yg diadaptasi yg ptama keinget kayanya Siti Nurbaya deh
    Yg karyanya Marah Rusli
    Dulu nonton movienya di TV (TVRI???) pas SD
    Trus baca novelnya
    Kbetulan si uwak dri Bandung beliin novel2 cetakan ulang
    Dan ternyata sama2 berkualitasnya
    Setting, penggambaran konflik, penjiwaan tokohnya jg bgitu memikat
    Novelnya sampai sekarang masuk jajaran novel lokal legendaris malah :hoho:


    Klo yg dri luar apaan yak :iii:
    Antara Jurassic Park (western) atau The Heavenly Sword and the Dragon Slaying Saber (Asian/Mandarin/Hongkong)
    Jurassic Park dah jelas pling mantep
    Bercokol slama beberapa tahun sebagai box office paling laris
    Karya legendaris Stephen Spielberg yg ampe skarang masih jadi acuan movie adatasi dri novel
    + penggunaan teknologi robot dlm movienya :sembah:
    Itu yg bikin penggambaran dunia novelnya bgitu hidup, nyata, dan membekas di ingatan
    Rasanya ini yg paling mampu menghidupkan dunia fantasi novel kedalam layar lebar :matabelo:


    Klo bt Dragon Slaying Saber
    Berhubung dulu novel wuxianya blum baca ya bagus2 aj
    Jdi salah satu movie wajib putar klo ada yg hajatan ngadain layar tancap
    Klo di Hongkongnya sendiri kurang sukses
    Scara banyak perbedaan ma yg dnovel :keringat:
    Makanya sekuelnya dcancel
    Bedanya ada 1chara cewek di movienya yg gabungan dri 4 chara cewek di novelnya
    Trus Xie Xun yg jadi pembawa inti masalahnya malah sama skali ga dlihatin
    7 Heroes of Wudang yg berperan penting jg ga ada sama skali (porsinya seuprit) :dead:




    Sawachika [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Jan 4, 2015
  16. Sunday_KNIGHT SUPERMOD

    Offline

    Rockstar

    Joined:
    Jun 10, 2012
    Messages:
    40,659
    Trophy Points:
    238
    Ratings:
    +756,115 / -5
    kebanyakan kalo udah adaptasi gini, gw gak pernah baca novelnya lagi dah,
    macam harpot misalnya, soalnya langsung lebih tertarik ke film,

    kecuali the lord of the ring, baca novelnya keren,
    pas di adaptasi ke film, rupanya jauh lebih keren,
    dan semenjak itu jadi suka dengan film hasil adaptasi dari novel/buku,

    biasanya film yang beginian, peta basarnya jadi keliatan, makanya suka aja :p
     
  17. wiwis6002 M V U

    Offline

    Senpai

    Joined:
    Mar 29, 2012
    Messages:
    9,139
    Trophy Points:
    202
    Gender:
    Female
    Ratings:
    +2,398 / -2
    sebelum orang kenal film memoir of geisha aku udah baca buku itu berkali kali setiap 3 bulan pas sma..
    emang dasarnya suka novel yang nyeritain budaya, apalagi yang bdayanya misterius gitu :hehe:
    nah seneng dong pas tau mw d adaptasi ke film, excited dong nontonnya :onegai:
    sampe beberapa menit d awal langsung :voodoo: apa apaan itu :sedih:
    emang sih antara novel sama film cara menceritakannya beda, tapi ini :sedih:
    gk mau komentar lebih lanjut :kecewa:


    film yg gk mengecewakan itu LOTR, emang susah payah bacanya, apalagi yang mas cetakan dulu, tulisan font 8, pake kertas buram :hihi:
    setelah nonton film nya, aku ngerasa berterimakasih sekali sama sutradara produser, scripwriter etc nya :sembah:
    emang bisa bikin film sampe 3 jam, tapi setiap detilnya memuaskan :blink::matabelo:


    secara pribadi aku lebih suka baca novel sebelum nonton filmnya :hmm:
    bahkan ketika film nya ud heboh banyak yang komentar, aku menahan diri untuk nyelesein novelnya sebelum nonton..
    karna menurutku baca versi novelnya malah bisa lebih tau apa yang ada d dalam kepala para tokohnya (soalnya gk paham kalo ngeliat ekspresi aktornya d film :hihi:)


    novel yang pengen d film kan~~
    apa ya??
    cek koleksi novel dulu deh :ngacir:
     
  18. aiana MODERATOR

    Offline

    Senpai

    Joined:
    Dec 25, 2011
    Messages:
    7,282
    Trophy Points:
    197
    Gender:
    Female
    Ratings:
    +2,544 / -1
    novel ke buku :matabelo:

    banyak yang bagus terutama lord of the rings sama the hobbit.nggak mengecewakan bener. :top:

    yang sedih adalah ceritanya eragon. .klo itu nggak di bikin ulang dari awal maka nggak akan bisa dibuat lanjutannya eldest, brisingr and inheritance :sigh:
    parah adaptasinya :hiks:
     
  19. Sunday_KNIGHT SUPERMOD

    Offline

    Rockstar

    Joined:
    Jun 10, 2012
    Messages:
    40,659
    Trophy Points:
    238
    Ratings:
    +756,115 / -5
    ^
    the hobbits .......... ? agak kecewa juga, soalnya satu buku di pecah jadi 3,
    kecewanya bukan di cerita / grafiknya, tapi dari bersambungnya itu ~
    terutama yang kedua itu, apa-apaan pulak di gantung seperti itu !!!
    :voodoo:

    tapi kalo sedikit meleset dari novel/buku aslinya, biasanya film-film disini akan langsung kacau dah,
    dan di series sana gak sedikit yang kena cancel karenanya,
    :keringat:
     
  20. fuikisama MODERATOR

    Offline

    Superstar

    Joined:
    Mar 24, 2012
    Messages:
    18,015
    Trophy Points:
    258
    Ratings:
    +23,392 / -180
    Somplak keduluan si mbah mo ngepost LotR :panda:


    Itu asli ajib bener bawain dunia di novelnya
    Klo bt design charanya rasanya yg goblin pling oye beserta ring armornya
    Denger2 dbuat manual itu armornya dri 200k ring :sembah:

    Itu citra elf Tolkien jg jadi base di novel2 lain
    Dmana elf selalu berkulit putih, tinggi2, tampan + cantik
    Biasa tinggal dhutan jdi pengawas/pelindung alam
    Ahli magic + expert penggunaan bow


    Btw si Peter Jackson ye directornya???

    Skarang lanjut ke Hobbit jg masih bagus movienya



    Klo Harpot rasanya yg paling sukses ngerealisasiin dunia sihir
    Ga begitu berlebihan tpi pas
    Design perlengkapan sihir, sekolah Hogwartsnya, ampe Quidditch
    Dulu ga kbayang malah kek paan Quidditch di novelnya :lol:

    Lebih berharap prekuel Harpot nyeritaiin Dumbledore sedari kecil/muda
    Ampe lawan black mage sebelum Voldemort + dtutup ma jadi kepsek Hogwarts

    Rasanya bkalan lebih ajib dbanding sekuel nyeritain kluarganya Harpot :garing:



    Sawachika [​IMG]
     
  21. aiana MODERATOR

    Offline

    Senpai

    Joined:
    Dec 25, 2011
    Messages:
    7,282
    Trophy Points:
    197
    Gender:
    Female
    Ratings:
    +2,544 / -1
    ^
    LOTR emang film yang bs bikin mata terbelalak kok.keren bener. .
    Haha maksud ai juga dari segi adaptasinya mbah yg the hobbit itu :keringat:
    Ai nunggu sih jd g kepotong ntnnya :XD:
    Adaptasi middle earth ke film bener2 ajaib. .
    Detailnya juga wow.

    --
    Adaptasi eragon ini menghilangkan beberapa part penting. Nah padahal part yg dihilangkan ini justru jd part yg peting di skuel lanjutannya :yareyare:
     
  22. kibikasoy MODERATOR

    Offline

    Lurking Around

    Joined:
    May 10, 2013
    Messages:
    1,275
    Trophy Points:
    222
    Gender:
    Male
    Ratings:
    +12,760 / -0
    Kalo Harpot kecewanya yg adaptasi buku ke-3 dan ke-5 rasanya kurang gmn gitu :keringat:
    karena ga dibuat sama persis sama buku jadi agak kecewa :swt:
    terus di yg ke-7 juga ngebayangin perang di Hogwarts lebih wah tapi ternyata cuma segitu di pelem

    yang lucu ane baca novel twilight dulu sampe tamat baru coba nonton pelemnya
    pas liat bling2 gitu jadi ga nonton lagi :lol:
     
  23. scarlet26 M V U

    Offline

    Post Hunter

    Joined:
    Apr 17, 2011
    Messages:
    3,629
    Trophy Points:
    222
    Gender:
    Female
    Ratings:
    +18,897 / -3
    hmm....
    ntah kenapa, kl baca novel lebih dapet feel-nya, bisa nyampe nangis bombay..
    menye-menye sekali...atau aku yg terlalu lemah
    :patahhati:
    ada 2 novel yg ku baca belum abis aja udh nangis", padahal pas nonton movie nya biasa aja
    Hafalan Sholat Delisa, Ayat-ayat Cinta
    nonton movie nya, ga terlalu jelek sih,
    cuma kurang dapet feel nya, ntah karna durasi atau emg adapt-nya ky gtu
    :bloon:

    trus,
    movie adapt.a bukunya raditya dika,
    udh baca Kambing jantan, Marmut merah jambu, cinta brontosaurus, manusia setengah salmon,
    dan jauuuhhh bgt..movie ama bukunya,
    bukunya bisa bikin ketawa ngakak sendiri,
    movie nya garing bgt
    :keringat:

    trus Bangun Lagi dong Lupus....aku udh ngfans lupus dari jaman SMP...
    alamaakkk pas di film-in di 2013 itu (udh masa sekarang)
    kirain masa sekarang kemampuan adaptnya makin bagus,
    ternyata garing bgt..
    :patahhati:

    di saranin temen baca tfios (udh nonton film nya dulu)
    temen nyuruh "Baca Novelnya dulu, baru nonton film-nya"
    berhubung belum sempet baca novelnya dah nonton movie-nya dulu..
    jadi ga niat beli... (karna ga terlalu menarik sih) :keringat:

    oia..ada yg movie n novel sama bagusnya sih (subjektif)
    Rectoverso...
    asli keren bgt..
    :terharu:
    nonton pun Feel-nya dapet...
    biarpun ada cerita yg beda dikit ama novel, tapi keren bgt adaptasinya..
    :terharu:
     
  24. fuikisama MODERATOR

    Offline

    Superstar

    Joined:
    Mar 24, 2012
    Messages:
    18,015
    Trophy Points:
    258
    Ratings:
    +23,392 / -180
    Ayat-Ayat Cinta

    [​IMG]
    Cover novel

    [​IMG]
    Poster movie

    Detail:
    Paperback, 418 pages
    Published: 2007 by Republika-Basmala (first published 2004)
    Original title: Ayat-ayat Cinta
    ISBN: 9832672368
    Edition language: Indonesian
    Genre: Romance
    Characters: Maria, Fahri bin Abdullah Shiddiq, Aisha, Nurul, Noura
    Setting: Egypt
    Literary awards: Anugerah Pena for Novel (2005)

    Tentang seorang pemuda Indonesia yang mencari ilmu jauh di tanah Arab. Berbekal iman yang kuat dan ketabahan, Fahri mengalami banyak hal yang menggetarkan hidupnya, yang sesaat membuat Fahri mempertanyakan jalan hidupnya.

    Kesabaran dan keimanan adalah kunci kehidupan. Fahri, Aisyah dan Maria membuktikannya dalam cerita yang halus dan mengalir.

    Ini buku pertengahan tahun 2000an ngehype bgt ma versi movienya jg
    Scara isi novel menarik jg dengan sisipan Islami didalamnya
    Soal penggambaran setting tempat maupun kehidupan sosial di Mesirnya jg cukup detail
    Maklum yg nulis dah terbiasa dsana (lulusan Al-Azhar University sih)

    Meski bt pencitraan charanya banyak yg nilai terlalu sempurna
    Kehidupan yg djalani utopis macemnya
    Tpi tetep masih ada berbagai sisi menariknya

    Adaptasi movienya jg bagus
    Rasanya karakter yg diperanin bisa hidup
    Fave si karena ada Riantinya :malu
    Demen aj ma tipikal cewek2 lembut :hahai:

    Terlepas dari berbagai kontroversi yg ada dari contentnya
    Ga bisa dipungkiri ini karya yg sukses n berbobot
    Bagaimana tidak kalau kehadirannya membuka jalan bagi beragam novel Islami lainnya
    Maupun geliat layar lebar Indonesia layaknya AADC dulu

    So be open minded n don't be too meanie :hihi:


    Over all rate:
    3,7/5




    Sawachika [​IMG]
     
    Last edited: Jan 4, 2015
  25. scarlet26 M V U

    Offline

    Post Hunter

    Joined:
    Apr 17, 2011
    Messages:
    3,629
    Trophy Points:
    222
    Gender:
    Female
    Ratings:
    +18,897 / -3
    kl adaptasi dari novel luar, ada 2 yg the best,
    movie nya (setara Rectoverso kl lokal)
    A walk to remember ama The Notebook
    lagi dan lagi...movie dan novel menye-menye
    :XD:

    film" macam The Hobbit, Lotr, ga gtu suka, pernah di ajakin temen nonton juga ga tertarik
    jadi novel pun malas buat baca
    :XD:
     
  26. IndoAnchovy M V U

    Offline

    Senpai

    Joined:
    Oct 23, 2010
    Messages:
    6,058
    Trophy Points:
    177
    Gender:
    Male
    Ratings:
    +3,916 / -0
    Di-tag ke SF Books, padahal ane orang yang jarang banget baca buku, apalagi novel. Baca Harry Potter az baru selesai jilid pertama dan jilid kedua tengah jalan ga lanjut2 lagi dari kemarin2 :keringat:

    Kalo nonton film adaptasi dari novel sih uda banyak juga, soalnya kan sekarang makin banyak az film yang diambil dari novel. Ntah karena para sutradara kehabisan ide, atau emank banyak novel keren akhir2, ntah lah :keringat:

    Pastinya Jurassic Park itu tetap jadi film TERFAVORIT ane dari dulu ampe sekarang ampe kapanpun, dan akhirnya tahun depan bakal muncul Jurassic World setelah sekian lama hanya berupa rumor :terharu:

    Edge Of Tomorrow juga diangkat dari light novel, walau ane kagak baca novelnya sih, cuma sekedar baca manganya doank :keringat:
     
  27. 12345678 M V U

    Offline

    Post Hunter

    Joined:
    Sep 25, 2009
    Messages:
    2,264
    Trophy Points:
    242
    Ratings:
    +9,944 / -0
    novel k movie... :matabelo:

    tb2 cm keinget satu yg masih agak jengkel.,,, itu waktu baca catching fire,, gw ud mempunyai imajinasi sedemikian rupa...... trnyt waktu difilmin si peetanya ga sesuaiiii............................ *ato mgkn ga sesuai sm imajinasiku kli y* huhuhuhu

    trs waktu city of bones juga..... penggambarannya mnrtku kurang sesuai sm yg di pilmnya............ :hiks: apa jgn2 aku yg salah imajinasi... :facepalm:
     
  28. hana_aulia M V U

    Offline

    Post Hunter

    Joined:
    Oct 18, 2010
    Messages:
    2,247
    Trophy Points:
    238
    Gender:
    Female
    Ratings:
    +7,250 / -0
    kalau ngomongin film atau movie yang diadaptasi dari novel, imho saya sih selalu suka versi buku atau novel
    dan sejauh ini blm pernah nonton movie atau film yg lebih bagus dari bukunya
    ntah kadang ada aja yg kurang, tokohnya lah...karakternya lah...settingannya lah...
    tapi mau gmn lagi...namanya jg novel, fantasi manusia itu sejagad, dijadiin gambaran real ya sulit :hehe:
    tapi ga tau klo LoTR ya...soalnya blm pernah baca bukunya, mau sih :XD: ada yg bersedia minjemin? :hoho:
    karena LoTR saya hanya pernah nonton movienya, dan menurut saya movienya epic bgt,
    jadi pas baca di page awal blg bukunya bagus, makin tertarik buat baca
    klo The Hobbit...di movie byk part yg miss...ntah kaya berasa ngulur cerita aja gtu, mgkn krn hanya dari 1 buku *walaupun blm pernah baca buku the hobbit jg*
    Klo Harry Potter, Bukunya udah keren bgt...movienya bisa adaptasi hampir 80% lah...
    klo mau bahas satu2 kayanya byk bgt buku yg saya baca terus diadaptasi ke novel...
    terakhir baca beberapa, kaya trilogi divergent *tokoh sama karakter ada bbrp perbedaan sma di buku*
    terus trilogi Maze Runner *byk miss nya jg...kuciwa dah :suram:
    skrg lagi baca novel The Giver...dan kebetulan blm nonton movie nya...smoga tidak mengecewakan :doa:
    ada 1 novel series yg saya suka bgt, novel The Alchemist cs. nya Michael Scott, khawatir klo ini novel dijadiin movie trs ga bagus
    soalnya keren bgt...fantasi bgt...
    oh iya, blm bahas yg novel lokal...sejauh ini yg saya anggap bagus adaptasinya...Laskar Pelangi nya andrea hirata :top:
    tapi cuma movie laskar pelanginya ya...sekuelnya...byk yg miss jg :sigh:
     
    • Thanks Thanks x 1
  29. 16aelene Veteran

    Offline

    Lurking Around

    Joined:
    Aug 6, 2012
    Messages:
    1,938
    Trophy Points:
    207
    Gender:
    Female
    Ratings:
    +59,872 / -0
    film adaptasi novel yg aku tonton dan aku bisa bilang bagus (yg masih aku inget) :

    semua Harry Potter, terutama nomer 1 dan 2,
    Angels and Demons,
    buku2 JRR Tolkien

    apalagi yaaa... :???:

    elene's logic :
    • kalo aku baca bukunya, aku males nonton film-nya,
    • dan kalo aku trlanjur nonton film nya :
      • kalo film-nya bagus, aku pasti kepengen baca bukunya, habis itu seringnya aku sadar bukunya jauh lbh bagus dari film-nya
      • kalo film nya ga bagus, aku pngen baca bukunya, curiga bukunya lbh bagus, kecuali ada temen yg kasih tau kalo bukunya jelek

    intinya aku lbh suka baca buku ktimbang nonton film :XD:

    banyak banget buku2 YA yg dibikin film, tp banyak banget yg film-nya jadi jelek banget.. :patahhati:

    yg baru2 ini bikin aku makin eneg sama film adaptasi > Fifty Shades :muntah:
     
  30. Lebah_Ganteng Members

    Offline

    Silent Reader

    Joined:
    Aug 9, 2012
    Messages:
    102
    Trophy Points:
    121
    Ratings:
    +17,251 / -0
    Bicara soal Novel diadaptsi ke film,
    pasti ada bagian2 yang dikurangi, jadi tentu lebih detail novel
    namun menurut saya, ini film bagus yang diadaptasi dari novel..

    LOTR
    HOBIT
    HERI POTER
    The Fault in Our Stars
    Angel & Demon
    Cloud Atlas

    Alasannya, adaptasinya bagus.

    Banyak seh, cuma tak pikir2 dulu yah :hihi:
     
  31. bluefin M V U

    Offline

    Post Hunter

    Joined:
    Feb 27, 2009
    Messages:
    4,049
    Trophy Points:
    227
    Gender:
    Male
    Ratings:
    +518,968 / -4
    bbrp yg ane baca kyk lotr trilogi, berhubung pas baca waktu smp jd pas liat filmnya entah knp lebih berkesan, mungkin daya imajinasi ane msh kurang ter develop dgn baik plus byk hal yg agak ribet dicerna jd mesti ulang2 bacanya pd wkt itu..
    setelah lotr, n hobbit difilmin ane berharap Silmarillion jg difilmin..

    harpot ane inget bli bukunya yg pertama sblm filmnya keluar dan ane enjoy bgt baca, pas filmnya keluar byk yg ga sreg sm filmnya antara laen gambaran ane ttg hermione, harpot sdr, gmn hogwarts, jd ane stop baca bukunya n nungguin filmnya aja.. denger2 buku ke 4 paling ga sejalan sm filmnya ya.. oiya dulu inget baca goosebumps nya rl stine, lengkap koleksi ane, ga di adapt ke movie sih, lebih tepatnya ke series, yg sm sekali ga serem kyk bukunya..
    the fault in our stars, bukunya keren, hyped bgt pas tau bakal dijadiin film, makanya di SF west movies bgt tau torrentnya dah keluar ane lgs buat threadnya jd TS tfios.. tetep berkaca2 (baca: mewek kyk anak kecil diambil permennya) pas ntn.. the feels..
    yg terakhir yg cukup berkesan, bukunya Francois Lelord judulnya Hector and the Search for Happiness.. bukunya menarik, mudah dipahami, ceritanya lucu, mungkin versi nyantainya eat pray love, tp buku ini jauuh lebih oke.. subyektif abis ya.. di filmnya apalagi yg meranin hector si simon pegg, jd lebih kocak..

    memoir of geisha ga baca, tp suka filmnya..

    klo lokal mungkin dr raditya dika kali ya.. filmnya garing bgt.. komedi di bukunya gagal bgt di filmnya, tp di film marmut merah jambu lumayan, mungkin faktor sutradara jg kali ya, krn di buku sebelumnya dikerjain sm rudi sujarwo cmiiw n terakhir sm dika sdr jd dia lbh tau apa yg pas/ga..
     
  32. nengNida MODERATOR

    Offline

    Superstar

    Joined:
    Dec 12, 2013
    Messages:
    10,874
    Trophy Points:
    253
    Gender:
    Female
    Ratings:
    +5,155 / -1
    wah jarang yang ngomongin film Indo ya:lol:

    film adaptasi novel pertama yang q baca itu adalah AAC, walaupun filmnya lumayan tp entah kenapa pas q nonton berasa ada yang kurang:sigh:
    lebih greget novelnya
    selain AAC, agak kecewa juga sama 5cm, terutama pas bagian akhirnya...yah, lumayan dech:hihi:

    klo harry potter suka banget pas awal baca novelnya dan ternyata filmnyapun luar biasa:terharu:
    cuma agak kecewa dengan film 5,6 dan 7 karena ada adegan yang beda dengan novelnya, selain itu pertempuran yang q bayangkan sangat seru pas baca novelnya ternyata difilmnya cuma gt ja:kecewa:
    tp overall HP ini masih tetap jadi favoritku dech:lalala:
     
  33. sersanjaka M V U

    Offline

    Lurking Around

    Joined:
    Jul 9, 2012
    Messages:
    967
    Trophy Points:
    92
    Ratings:
    +683 / -0
    Setelah baca trit ini jadi nyadar kok buanyakk banget ya cerita novel yg diangkat ke tipi?? Eh kalo cerita marvel yg diangkat jd Avengers tu ngga termasuk ya?? :haha: kalo termasuk sih gw mau nominasiin "Stand by me" nya Doraemon, itu 95% sama ama komiknya

    Film adaptasi yg aku baca novelnya duluan trus nonton filmnya umm apa aja ya. Harry Potter 1-7, Catching Fire/ Mockingjay, Eragon, Da Vinci Code, Angels & Demonsummm apa lagi ya... oya Jomblo, 5cm juga.

    Yg menurut gw paling oke Catching Fire sih, itu stay true sama novelnya... yg gw sesalkan justru pas adegan makan2 di Capitol ngga diperlihatkan makanan2nya :XD:
    Yg paling nggak oke... mungkin Eragon yah. Wajar sih, budget nya kesedot abis dibuat bikin Saphira :haha: Tapi yang paling "beda" malah kyknya Da Vinci Code, bukan karena beda sama novelnya.. tapi GREGET nya beda. Entah kenapa kalo baca Novel nya kyk lebih seru - padahal ngadaptasinya udah bener. Cuma kyk lebih degdegan aja pas baca bukunya

    Btw btw btw,, gw baru tahu lho kalo di The Hobbit itu sebenernya karakter Lauriel eh MAAP SALAH, Tauriel itu sebenernya nggak ada di novel aslinya!!! Dia sengaja di-create buat jadi bumbu2 penyedap cinta2 gitu deh... :haha: Oya dan gw jg penah baca kalo Thranduil, se-fabulous apapun Lee Pace memerankannya, tp di buku Hobbit aslinya dia karakternya ngga arogan kyk Thranduil nya Peter Jackson, tp baik dan actually peduli sama manusia, bahkan Bilbo pun suka sama dia. Tp utk baca novelnya Tolkien rasanya gw gak sanggup :XD: bahasanya nggak nyambung :hmm:
     
    • Like Like x 1
    Last edited: Jan 12, 2015
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page

About Forum IDWS

IDWS, dari kami yang terbaik-untuk kamu-kamu (the best from us to you) yang lebih dikenal dengan IDWS adalah sebuah forum komunitas lokal yang berdiri sejak 15 April 2007. Di bangun sebagai sarana mediasi dengan rekan-rekan pengguna IDWS dan memberikan terbaik untuk para penduduk internet Indonesia menyajikan berbagai macam topik diskusi.